
Daily Cupcake Flavors
Flavors are available daily during the following hours: Monday–Friday: 12:00 PM – 5:00 PM Saturday: 10:00 AM – 5:00 PM Any flavor not listed as available during operating hours can still be ordered by the dozen only with a minimum of 24 hours advance notice, with a lead time of 4 hours from our regular business hours.
Regular Cupcakes
We offer a daily selection of our delicious regular flavored cupcakes available in-store, sold individually or by the dozen. You can purchase up to 2 dozen cupcakes in-store on the spot. For orders of more than 2 dozen, we kindly ask that you place your order at least 24 hours in advance. Our cupcakes are slightly larger than standard size, baked in European liners for a more generous portion. We also keep our buttercream balanced—not overly piled—making them perfect for sharing!
Butter Pecan
Pecans baked in the cupcake and pecans in Butter Pecan flavored buttercream, topped with pecans.
$3.95
Chocolate Oreo
Dark chocolate Oreo cookie baked at the bottom. A pure delight when you bite into it. What a sweet surprise!
$3.95
Chocolate with Vanilla Buttercream
$3.95
Chocolate with Chocolate Buttercream
$3.95
Coconut
Rich coconut cake topped with a flavorful coconut buttercream and topped with coconut flakes.
$3.95
Confetti
Vanilla cake with sprinkles baked inside. A kid's delight!
$3.95
Cookies & Cream
A regular Oreo cookie baked at the bottom of the cupcake. Topped with Cookie and Cream buttercream and a mini Oreo cookie.
$3.95
Lemon
A balanced lemon cupcake that is not too sweet and not too tart. Topped with lemon buttercream and yellow sprinkles.
$3.95
Lemon Blueberry
Customer's favorite! A well-balanced lemon cupcake baked with fresh blueberries inside. Topped with a savory lemon buttercream and blueberry Yum Yum Crumbs.
$3.95
Peanut Butter
Baked with peanut butter in the batter. Topped with a rich and smooth peanut butter buttercream, topped with a mini chocolate Reese's peanut butter candy
$3.95
Strawberry
Delicious strawberry cupcake with fresh strawberry buttercream and a strawberry kiss on top!
$3.95
Vanilla with Vanilla Buttercream
$3.95
Vanilla with Chocolate Buttercream
$3.95
Wedding White (Almond Base)
This almond-based cupcake is incredibly rich and flavorful—so much so, one customer described it as “like taking a bite of heaven.” Topped with a perfectly balanced almond buttercream, it’s a treat you won’t want to finish… but won’t be able to resist.
$3.95
Specialty Cupcakes
We offer a daily selection of our delicious specialty flavored cupcakes available in-store, sold individually or by the dozen. You can purchase up to 2 dozen cupcakes in-store on the spot. For orders of more than 2 dozen, we kindly ask that you place your order at least 24 hours in advance. Our cupcakes are slightly larger than standard size, baked in European liners for a more generous portion. We also keep our buttercream balanced—not overly piled—making them perfect for sharing!
Banana Split
Banana cupcake filled with fresh strawberry compote, a delicious choice of chocolate or vanilla buttercream, topped with chocolate sauce, strawberry sauce, freshly made whip cream and a cherry on top.
$4.50
Boston Creme
Yellow cupcake filled with a Bavarian Creme, topped with a rich chocolate ganache and eclair Yum, Yum crumbs.
$4.50
Carrot
A rich, old-fashioned carrot cake bursting with warm spices, shredded carrots, crunchy pecans, sweet coconut, and pineapple for Mrs. Grace's extra special touch of flavor.
$4.50
Chocolatey Chocolate
A moist chocolate cupcake filled with luscious fresh chocolate crème, topped with creamy chocolate buttercream, mini chocolate chips, and a drizzle of rich chocolate ganache — pure chocolate bliss in every bite!
$4.50
Chocolate Caramel
A moist chocolate cupcake filled with thick, dolce de leche caramel sauce, topped with smooth chocolate buttercream, drizzled with caramel sauce, and sprinkled with crunchy caramel pieces for the perfect balance of sweet and indulgent.
$4.50
German Chocolate
For our German Chocolate aficionados, this one’s for you! We serve up a rich, authentic German chocolate cupcake topped with our freshly made German chocolate frosting — crafted with the finest ingredients. Please note: frosting contains pecans and coconut.
$4.50
Italian Cream
This vanilla-based cupcake is infused with flavorful rum extract and baked with pecans and coconut for a rich, tropical twist. It’s topped with a smooth, creamy cream cheese frosting and finished with sliced almonds for the perfect crunch. Contains pecans and coconut.
$4.50
Peach Cobbler
This is Mrs. Grace’s beloved recipe — a warm blend of spices and juicy peaches that brings the comforting taste of peach cobbler to cupcake form. Topped with her signature homemade whipped cream, it’s one-of-a-kind and unforgettable. You won’t find another like it!
$4.50
Red Velvet
This exquisite cupcake needs no introduction. Savor a moist, classic red velvet cake crowned with luxuriously smooth and rich cream cheese frosting.
$4.50
Strawberriest Strawberry
A dream come true for strawberry enthusiasts! This strawberry cupcake is filled with fresh strawberry compote, topped with our homemade whipped cream, and finished with a drizzle of sweet strawberry sauce.
$4.50
Salted Caramel
A vanilla-based cupcake infused with rich salted caramel flavor. Topped with velvety cream cheese frosting and drizzled with luscious salted caramel sauce for the perfect sweet-and-salty finish.
$4.50
White Chocolate Raspberry
A true indulgence! This decadent white chocolate cupcake is filled with freshly made raspberry compote, then topped with smooth vanilla buttercream, rich white chocolate ganache, and finished with a sprinkle of white chocolate chips. No wonder it’s one of the baker’s favorites!
$4.50
Gluten Friendly Cupcakes
Our Gluten-Friendly cupcakes are made with the finest gluten free flour, and we offer delicious buttercreams to pair perfectly with your favorite cupcake flavor. Want to mix and match? Go for it — create your own flavor combination with our daily flavors of Chocolate, Strawberry or Vanilla cupcakes and multitude of flavored buttercreams!
Chocolate
$4.50
Strawberry
$4.50
Vanilla
$4.50
Vegan Cupcakes
Our vegan cupcakes are made without eggs or dairy, and we offer delicious dairy-free buttercreams to pair perfectly with your favorite cupcake flavors. Want to mix and match? Go for it — create your own flavor combination with our daily flavors! If you're simply looking for egg-free cupcakes and don't have dairy restrictions, we can also top your cupcakes with our regular buttercream flavors.
Chocolate
$4.50
Strawberry
$4.50
Vanilla
$4.50
Other Everyday Delicious Options
Chocolate Covered Pretzels
$1.50
Brookie's
Our Brookies are the best of both worlds — a thick, rich, fudgy brownie baked with fresh chocolate chip cookie dough that melts in your mouth. Warm it up, add a scoop of ice cream, and you've got yourself a slice of pure happiness!
$6.75
Individual Banana Pudding Cups
Our Banana Pudding Cups are simply scrumptious! Made with layers of fresh vanilla crème, crunchy vanilla wafers, ripe banana slices, and topped with our homemade whipped cream — it’s a classic comfort dessert done right.
$7.89
Individual Strawberry Shortcake Cake
This Is One Piece of Cake You Won’t Want to Share! Once you take a bite, you’ll understand why — because when it’s gone, you’ll wish you had more! It’s a slice of pure happiness: fresh vanilla cake layered with creamy vanilla crème, swirled with strawberry compote, and topped with our homemade whipped cream. This dessert has become a customer favorite — so much so that people travel from out of town just to get a slice. Yes, yes… we definitely Bake You Happy!
$9.89
Sliced Original Pound Cake
One bite, and you'll be transported back to grandma’s kitchen. Our Pound Cake is a thick slice of classic, old-fashioned vanilla cake — no icing, just rich, buttery goodness. It freezes beautifully, too, so feel free to purchase multiple slices or call to purchase a whole cake. If you do freeze it, simply let it come to room temperature or warm it in the microwave for about 15 seconds. Pair it with your favorite beverage, and you’re right back to those cherished childhood memories.
$5.50